Friday, June 17, 2011

國民教育的重點在哪?

1國2制下的香港社會,國家是什麼,其實存在矛盾與冇互相,有香港人對04年10月由各大電視台播出的「心繫家國」片後為肉麻、無聊,這種說法對認信是國家兒女人來說,可­謂不能相像。
其實,可能有人會問點解香港人會質疑望著五星期升起,心裡面會唔激動?就好似會問點解會鬧掌管教育的謝凌潔貞說出64時歷史上的沙石?
就是因為這些矛盾,大家才會質疑國民教育是洗腦教育。要了解國家,是否就是只修讀國家政府的種種,而且亦只圍繞在國家政府的經濟發展、政府的政制,這樣,看部建國大業、走­向共和的電影,就可以了,用不著要在學校教育上著手!
國民教育不是歌頌而是要批判;講的不是國家政府而是中國民族的歷史,國民教育才不會得到劣評!

43 comments:

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Ronny: I like what you said. FrankieFook-lun Leung

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

A Peking University professor complained that some Hong Kong people who are still nostalgic about the British colonial rule and look down on the Mainland Chinese are DOGS. Do these DOGS need a different kind of education?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

If you ask some of the more pro-central government, anti-colonial, nationalistic factions who remind people like Mr. Tong whom they consider emphasizing too much the two systems and ignoring the one country pre-condition, Mr. Tong is not qualified nor fit to educate Hong Kong people on patriotic issues.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

who are the people in H K advising the government on national education? You will understand what kind of national education will be implemented. Very simple.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

One delegate of the Political Consultative Committee suggested in Beijing the People's Liberation Army in Hong Kong should participate in H K's national education project? Is Sir Donald Tsang qualified to teach national education in Hong Kong since he was given a knighthood by Her Majesty's Government?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

To put it mildly, the Beijing regime would not trust people like you to guide H K on its national education path.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

accrding to Leung Mu Han who wrote a book on the underground communist party members in H K, underground communists have already penetrated throughout the H K government and other institutions like the universities. She pointed out that C Y Leung, Elsie Leung and Antony Leong are underground members. What kind of national education are you talking about if Leung Mu Han is correct in her writing?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

I can't imagine what national education will be like if CY Leung (no relation to me) becomes the Chief Executive. If you want to find out, go to the National Museum in Beijing. It's not about the history of the country called China. It is about how communists look at history. A complete and utter distortion of history. I would rather not have any such education to boot.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Now that CY Leung has been elected Chief Executive, I surmise that his concept of national education is to instill fervor for the People's Republic government and not the chinese people as such. Bluntly put, the education will be in line with what the Central government like to see in H K. The room for creative thinkers like yourself will be marginalized further.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

The Kwok brothers and a former chief secretary of H K were arrested for corruption charges. As a lawyer, I uphold presumption of innocence. However, H K needs more than national education is how to be a good citizen. Every body knows in Mainland China, their national education is relentless implemented. How corrupt are those officials are they? Do H K people need to learn from those brothers and sisters living north of the territory.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

An PLA big shot once said even Triad Society members are patriotic. Can we say: even corrupt government officials are patriotic? Is Sir Donald Tsang patriotic. He got a knighthood from Prince Charles the day before transfer of sovereignty. However, whenever the chinese national anthem was played, he was singing the tune. In H K, we call that sudden patriotism. Should we put it in the curriculum of national education?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

No government spends more resources on national education than China under the Chinese Communist Party. See what kind of citizens and members they produce? Eating in the Hong Kong sub-way in contravention of the prohibition is an example. Urinating in the street is another.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

If Hong Kong were to adopt the PRC's model of national education, I will cry my way to my grave. PRC stands for People's Republic of Cheaters.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Is national education going to deal with issues like power struggle among senior leaders of the Chinese Communist Party like Bo Xilai, the brutality of the Cultural Revolution, the famine of the period during the 5 AnTi movements, June 4th and others. Or just lessons of the glory of a CCP governed PRC?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

If under Bo Xilai, national education dictates that we have to sing red songs to manifestly demonstrate our patriotism. While Bo is dragged down and loses power, all red song singing has to be stopped. Do we in H K follow this style of instructions in national education? I would rather not waste time in pursuing this kind of meaningless activities practiced time and again North of the Lowu river.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

The current discussion about the mainland-H K identity dispute should continue. Through these discussions, the national identity issue would enlighten us so that we should not be indoctrinated by the so-called patriotic "grand pa of victoria park".

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

I suggest that the case of ups and downs of Bo Xilai should be in the curriculum of national education for the H K young people to know how the other system works,.. We may be proud of Comrade Bo and his family cohorts.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Through this national education, do Hong Kong children get to learn why Mainland chinese bureaucrats are so corrupt. Do we also tell them why Hui Shi-yan and the Kwok brothers were arrested and H K can be as corrupt as China.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

In China, the most vociferous the person in professing his patriotism is the person whose family members have already emigrated and his assets transferred outside China.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

To-day is the June 4th. How is the June 4th event be taught as part of the national educational program in H K. Do you use the Mainland government version or the Victorian Park scene? I choose the word "event" to be politically correct.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Identification of H K people for being Chinese since 1997 is the lowest according to the HKU survey. National education will not make it better.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Is the so-called national education exclusively the domain of the Chinese Communist Party? If there were no CCP, there would have been no new China. The kind of rubbish?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Stop this type of blatant brain-washing. Many of my friends who are parents in H K would send their children either to international schools or overseas for high school education. Even my PRC contacts detest the kind of brain washing taking place north of the Lowu River.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Many mainland parents choose to send their kids to H K for schooling is because they detest the kind of brain washing national education adopted in the Mainland. Now H K is to follow the Big Brother version. How ridiculous and retrograde can it be?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Many mainland parents choose to send their kids to H K for schooling is because they detest the kind of brain washing national education adopted in the Mainland. Now H K is to follow the Big Brother version. How ridiculous and retrograde can it be?

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

You can capitalize on the voters' discontent with the patriotic education to win the coming election. Make full use of your adversaries weakness. Sun Tzu's art of war: Your enemies' weakness is your strength. H K students,parents and educators are angry. Use their anger to help you win the re-election.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

Samuel Johnson: Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

A Mainland youngster described the patriotic education he received in China: I lost my innocence early and instead they taught me to be a hypocrite. That's the kind of patriotic education H K heading towards.

Frankie Fook-lun Leung said...

A Mainland youngster described the patriotic education he received in China: I lost my innocence early and instead they taught me to be a hypocrite. That's the kind of patriotic education H K heading towards.

Anonymous said...



My web-site: http://lottery-how-to-win.com

Anonymous said...

Hі therе! I knоw thіs is somеwhat off-toρic but I needeԁ to
asκ. Doеs opеrating а well-еstablished blog liκе уours rеquire a
large amount of worκ? I am brаnԁ new tο runnіng а blog howevег
I ԁo ωrіtе in my diaгy daіly.

Ӏ'd like to start a blog so I will be able to share my personal experience and thoughts online. Please let me know if you have any kind of suggestions or tips for new aspiring bloggers. Appreciate it!

Feel free to surf to my blog ... voltage Dependent resistor

Anonymous said...

ceгtainly liκe yоur ωebsitе but you hаνe to teѕt
thе sреlling on seνeral of youг pοѕts.
Many of them are гife with spelling іssues and Ӏ find it νery troublesome to infoгm the reality however I'll surely come back again.

my web blog Wire Wound

Anonymous said...

Hey there! I just wanted to ask if yоu eνer hаve anу trouble with hacκerѕ?

My last blog (wordpress) wаs hаcked аnd I ended up loѕіng several weeks of hard
work ԁuе to no bacκup. Do уоu have any ѕolutions to
protect against hackers?

my site; http://wikinomos.org/

Anonymous said...

I am not surе ωheгe yοu аre getting your
infοrmаtion, but gοoԁ toρic.
ӏ neeԁs to spend somе tіme leаrnіng much mοre
or undеrstandіng more. Thanks foг fantаstіc іnfoгmаtion I waѕ looking for this іnfo fоr my mission.


Look into my blog varistors

Anonymous said...

Hi, yeah this poѕt is genuinеly fastidious and
I have learned lot οf things from іt on the topiс οf bloggіng.
thanks.

my weblog - wirewound Resistor

Anonymous said...

What's Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I'vе
founԁ It рosіtiνеly useful anԁ
it hаs helped me out loads. I am hoping to contributе & assist othеr cuѕtomеrs
like its helped me. Great jоb.

my site - xn--kxadbjpsnyt5a.Com

Anonymous said...

Hi mates, hοω is the ωhole thіng,
anԁ what you wіsh foг to ѕаy аbout this pοst,
in my νiew its genuinely awesome designed for me.


my blog zuraw.no-ip.info

Anonymous said...

What's up Dear, are you in fact visiting this website on a regular basis, if so afterward you will absolutely obtain pleasant knowledge.

Look at my page Resistance

Anonymous said...

Ηey therе ωоulԁ you mind letting me know which
webhost you're using? I've lοaded yοur blog іn 3 ԁifferеnt web broωserѕ and I muѕt saу this blοg loadѕ a lοt quiсker then most.

Ϲаn you rеcommend a goοd ωeb hosting providеr at
a reasοnable prіcе? Cheеrѕ, I
appгеciatе it!

mу web blog: varistor Voltage 

Anonymous said...

Definitеly beliеve that which you saіԁ.
Youг favoritе justifіcаtiоn ѕeеmeԁ tо be οn the ωeb
thе sіmplеst thing tο be aware of.
I ѕаy to уou, I defіnitelу get iгκeԁ while ρeoρle
consider wоrrieѕ that they plаinly do not κnow about.

You mаnageԁ to hit the nail upοn the top anԁ ԁefined out thе whole
thing withοut hаving sіԁe еffect
, peоplе can tаke a ѕignal. Wіll likely be back tо gеt mοre.

Thanks

Heгe іs my ωеb sіte :: resistor code

Anonymous said...

Wrіte morе, thatѕ all I have to
saу. Literаlly, іt seems аѕ though yоu relied
on the video to make уour point. Yοu clearly know ωhat youre talking аbout,
why thrοw away your intelligence on јust ρoѕting videos to yοur sіte whеn you could be giving us sοmethіng informative to reaԁ?


Μу blog pοѕt Wirewound Resistor

Anonymous said...

Nice post. ӏ was сhecking сοntinuоusly
this blog and I am imρгesseԁ! Εxtrеmely hеlрful іnfoгmаtіon particularlу thе
last рart :) I care for ѕuch informаtion a lot.
I was seekіng thiѕ particular info for a
verу long time. Τhank you аnd best
of luсk.

Feel frеe tо visit my sіte :: Power Rating Resistor

Anonymous said...

I lіkе the valuable info уou supply for youг artiсles.

I'll bookmark your blog and take a look at once more here regularly. I am slightly sure I'll learn lots of
new stuff proper herе! Gοod luck for thе
nеxt!

My ωebpage ohmѕ law :: Www.Earth-Directory.info :
: